Differences , applications , and advantages of Sinker EDM and wire EDM

The development of high-precision machining technology has revolutionized manufacturing, with EDM being a leading innovation. This is particularly true of two commonly used high-precision machining techniques: Sinker and Wire EDM. These two distinct yet interconnected non-traditional machining processes each have their advantages and are suitable for different applications. Today, we’ll explore the key differences, best uses, and benefits of these two methods. Our goal is to help you make the right choice based on your unique manufacturing needs, which is crucial for businesses requiring custom-made high-precision parts.

What is electrical discharge machining (EDM) in manufacturing?

Electrical discharge machining (EDM), also known as spark machining or electrical spark etching, is a non-traditional precision machining process that uses controlled electrical discharges or “sparks” to remove material from a conductive workpiece. Unlike traditional machining methods that require physical contact between the tool and the workpiece, EDM is a non-contact process, making it ideal for machining complex parts and hard metals such as titanium, tungsten, and hardened steel.

Electrical discharge machining (EDM) generates a high-frequency current between two electrodes: a tool electrode (cutting tool) and a workpiece electrode (material to be machined). The EDM process involves immersion in a dielectric fluid (typically deionized water or hydrocarbon oil, used for insulation and cooling) .

Basic building blocks of EDM equipment and systems

The following are the basic components of electrical discharge machining (EDM) equipment and systems, which can help us understand how they work and why they can manufacture high-precision custom parts.

Dielectric fluid	A dielectric fluid is injected into the space between the electrode tool and the workpiece, immersing both in the process. Furthermore, a constant pressure must be maintained for the dielectric fluid flow to remove any corroded metal from the workpiece. Excessive fluid pressure may accelerate the removal of metal chips, thus slowing down the cutting process. If the fluid pressure is too low, unexpelled chips from the corrosion process may cause a short circuit in the system. Ethylene glycol, silicone oil, and deionized water are the most commonly used dielectric fluids in this process.
Spark generator	This component provides the precise voltage required for spark generation and discharge maintenance. It produces 100,000 sparks per second.
DC pulse generator	This component converts AC power to DC power with a pulse intensity strong enough to ignite a spark between the workpiece and the etching tool.
Servo motor mechanism	This mechanism manages the tool feed and movement of the EDM machine tool. As mentioned earlier, a programmable servo motor mechanism is responsible for the critical control of the arc gap.
Electrode tools	The system components are mounted on a tool holder and connected to the cathode of the power supply. Your tool’s profile will match the exact profile left in your work area. The process maintains a tiny gap between the electrode tool and the workpiece, which manufacturing engineers call the arc gap. The most popular electrode materials are graphite, steel, cast iron, copper, and tungsten alloys.
workpiece	Since the anode and the working part are connected, this completes the ecosystem of the electrical discharge machining (EDM) machine. A high-quality electrical conductor is required for the working part to make the process feasible.

What is Sinker EDM machining technology?

Sinker EDM is a form of electrical discharge machining used to create complex-shaped cavities in workpieces. The equipment operates at spark temperatures up to 12,000°C. EDM tolerances are as low as ±0.005 mm. It can achieve a surface finish of 0.1 μm Ra. During this process, the operator uses a tool with the desired cavity shape. This tool is typically lowered slowly into the workpiece to etch some of its parts and create a cavity that matches the tool’s shape. Hydrocarbon oil is used as the dielectric fluid in EDM. Some applications of Sinker EDM include mold making, rapid machining, creating deep, thin ribs, and creating sharp internal angles.

The core working principle of an EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining) settling plate machine

This process requires an insulating fluid, electrodes, and a power source. The electrodes and workpiece are connected via the power source. An electric spark is generated between the electrodes and the workpiece. The high temperatures produced by the spark, ranging from 8,000 to 12,000°C, can melt any surface in contact. Unlike wire EDM, this process does not completely cut through the material, allowing the operator to control specific areas very carefully and focus on machining complex shapes. Furthermore, it does not generate stress in the material. This makes EDM one of the best processes for machining precision parts.

What is wire electrical discharge machining technology?

Wire EDM is an electrical discharge machining process that uses a fine wire as its primary tool. The metal wire, typically 0.1 to 0.3 mm in diameter, acts as an electrode and generates a controlled discharge to etch the workpiece. This advanced technology enables fine cuts with a minimum kerf width of 0.02 mm and tolerances up to ±0.001 mm. This process is used for thorough cutting of the workpiece, distinguishing it from wire EDM. In wire EDM, operators typically use deionized water as its dielectric fluid. With wire EDM, a metal wire is connected between two diamond guides that move along the X and Y axes. Sparks are then generated, etching the workpiece. Wire EDM is effective for machining extrusion dies, punches, and parts with precision tolerances.

The core working principle of wire EDM machines

Its working principle is similar to band sawing, although a metal wire is used instead of a workpiece during the cutting process. The wire is typically made of brass or copper, and high voltage electricity enables it to cut through the thickness of the workpiece. Cutting can begin from the edge of the material, or holes can be drilled in the workpiece to allow the wire to pass through, making it easier to cut from the inside. Additionally, deionized water is used for highly controlled electrical conductivity. The deionized water cools the final part and washes away any removed particles. Wire EDM provides extremely precise cuts, enabling manufacturers to perform complex and precise machining on the most complex and delicate shapes of precision parts.

The difference between electrical discharge machining (EDM) and wire cutting.

Electrical discharge machine tools are a general term for electrical discharge forming machine tools and electrical discharge wire cutting machine tools. The processing principles of electrical discharge forming machine tools and electrical discharge wire cutting machine tools are the same.

Generally speaking, electrical discharge machining (EDM) refers to an EDM forming machine tool, while wire cutting refers to an EDM wire cutting machine tool. The difference between them is that EDM uses forming electrodes, while wire cutting uses electrode wires.

Electrical discharge machining (EDM) machines are mostly used for cavity machining, such as mold making and precision parts processing; especially with the adoption of CNC technology, it has become possible to process complex-shaped parts with simple electrodes. Wire EDM, on the other hand, is mainly used to process through holes and shapes. Wire EDM uses the reciprocating motion of an electrode wire to cut parts like a saw; its disadvantage is that it can only process parts that run vertically through.

In addition, wire EDM machines are further divided into fast wire EDM and slow wire EDM. As the names suggest, this distinction is based on the speed of the electrode wire’s movement. Fast wire EDM generally uses molybdenum wire as the electrode wire, which is used in a cyclic manner. It has relatively high processing efficiency but lower precision. Slow wire EDM uses copper wire as the electrode wire, resulting in lower processing efficiency but higher precision; it typically requires 3-4 cuts.

Comparison of differences between electrical discharge machining and wire cutting machining

Although both Sinker EDM and Wire EDM fall under the category of Electrical Discharge Machining, they differ in many ways. This section aims to provide a detailed comparison of the two based on several factors.

process

The core difference between these technologies lies in the electrode movement and type. Submerged EDM uses a shaped electrode immersed in the workpiece to create a three-dimensional cavity. It primarily works along the Z-axis with a spark gap of 0.010 to 0.500 mm. In contrast, wire EDM uses a thin wire (0.02 to 0.33 mm in diameter) that moves along the X and Y axes. This wire cuts the entire thickness of the workpiece. It continuously unfolds from the spool and maintains a fixed diameter throughout the cutting process.

Geometric design and manufacturing capabilities

Sinker EDM can manufacture complex shapes and intricate 3D cavities up to 400 mm deep. Featuring steep angles (up to 45 degrees) and sharp internal angles, it is the ideal choice for deep cavity and mold making.

Wire EDM is ideal for cutting through holes and precise 2D contours. It can achieve very narrow kerf widths of 0.02 mm and produce complex contours with precise radii. This method is highly effective in producing components with complex perimeters and complex flat parts.

Surface finish and precision

Both electrical discharge machining (EDM) methods can produce high-precision parts, but wire EDM typically achieves a finer surface finish. The surface roughness of EDM ranges from 0.4 to 1.6 μm Ra, while wire EDM can achieve a fineness of 0.1 μm Ra.

In terms of manufacturing precision, electrical discharge machining (EDM) typically has a tolerance of ±0.013 mm, while wire EDM can achieve a strict tolerance of ±0.003 mm. Furthermore, wire EDM offers better control over surface texture, making it more suitable for applications requiring specific micro-textures or very smooth surfaces.

Material compatibility

Both machining techniques are compatible with materials of varying strengths. Sinker EDM is ideal for machining conductive, hard materials such as carbides, tool steels, and superalloys. It is particularly suitable for machining high-melting-point metals and heat-resistant alloys.

Wire EDM offers greater flexibility in terms of materials. While it is also suitable for conductive materials, it can handle a wider range of materials, such as brass, aluminum, and some rare alloys. Both methods require conductive workpieces with a resistivity below 100 Ω·cm to achieve optimal performance.

Manufacturing speed and processing efficiency

Wire EDM is generally more efficient and faster than Sinker EDM, especially for larger workpieces. Wire EDM can perform continuous cuts, thus removing material much faster, particularly on larger workpieces. While Sinker EDM is slower, drop EDM is very useful for manufacturing complex 3D cavities in a single step. For small, complex parts requiring multiple wire EDM setups, drop EDM is much faster.

Requirements for professional tools

These two technologies differ significantly in their tooling requirements. Sinker EDM requires custom-shaped electrodes, typically made of copper or graphite. These molds are designed to match the desired cavity shape. These electrodes can be expensive and difficult to fabricate, especially for complex shapes.

Wire EDM only requires a simple, continuously fed brass wire electrode, which is typically made of brass. Drop EDM’s custom electrodes allow for the creation of more complex 3D shapes, while wire EDM is limited to 2D cutting contours.

Operating costs

Wire EDM offers faster cutting speeds and simpler tools, generally resulting in lower operating costs. However, the frequent need to replace wire EDM devices can increase overall costs. Sinker EDM, on the other hand, requires custom electrodes, so the initial tooling costs for this process can be higher. However, for complex 3D geometries or situations requiring many identical parts, EDM machines may be more economical.

Similarities between wire cutting and electrical discharge machining

Aside from the many differences, we do see some similarities between electrical discharge machining (EDM) and wire EDM:

Basic principles	Both work on similar principles, namely electrical discharge etching.
Mechanical stress	Neither the settling plates nor the wires come into contact with the workpiece, so they do not generate stress on it.
Dielectric	Both of these operations require a dielectric material to be performed.
Machining hard materials	Both are only applicable to conductive metals and hard materials that are difficult to machine with conventional tools.
Customization and flexibility	Wire electrical discharge machining (EDM) helps create custom cavities, while wire EDM helps create custom profiles.

Comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of Sinker EDM and Wire EDM manufacturing technologies

Like any manufacturing process, these two precision manufacturing technologies each have their own advantages and disadvantages. Next, we will compare the advantages and disadvantages of Sinker EDM and Wire EDM manufacturing technologies in a table.

Aspect	Sinker EDM – Advantages	Sinker EDM – Disadvantages	Wire EDM – Advantages	Wire EDM – Disadvantages
Machining Capability	Excellent for complex 3D cavities, blind features, deep ribs, and sharp internal corners	Not suitable for through-cut profiles or long straight cuts	Ideal for precise 2D and 2.5D through-cut profiles with high accuracy	Limited to through cuts; cannot create blind cavities
Precision & Accuracy	High repeatability for intricate cavity shapes	Generally lower dimensional accuracy than Wire EDM for straight profiles	Very high dimensional accuracy and straightness	Accuracy decreases on very thick parts or complex tapers
Surface Finish	Capable of fine surface finishes and controlled textures	May require polishing depending on finish requirements	Excellent surface finish with minimal burrs	Fine finishes increase machining time
Tooling & Setup	Can machine hardened materials without cutting forces	Requires custom electrodes that increase preparation time	No custom tooling beyond wire and guides	Initial setup and programming can be time-consuming
Design Flexibility	Can replicate complex negative geometries	Electrode wear affects dimensional consistency	Easily cuts intricate profiles and tight internal corners	Geometry limited by wire diameter and kerf width
Productivity	Effective for deep cavities and complex forms	Slower material removal rate compared to milling	High accuracy with unattended operation	Slower than conventional cutting for thick sections
Cost Factors	Suitable for high-value tooling and mold components	Electrode fabrication increases cost	Lower tooling cost for complex profiles	Consumable wire and machine time add operating cost
Material Compatibility	Works well with hardened steels, carbides, and superalloys	Limited to electrically conductive materials	Excellent for hard and exotic conductive materials	Non-conductive materials cannot be machined
Thermal Effects	No mechanical stress on parts	Heat-affected layer may require post-processing	Minimal distortion due to low cutting forces	Recast layer may need removal for critical applications
Typical Use Cases	Mold cores, cavities, die-casting molds, complex tooling	Not economical for simple or open geometries	Punches, dies, precision plates, gears, laminations	Not suitable for enclosed or 3D cavity features

Application industries of the two technologies

Some industries use both electrical discharge machining (EDM) techniques to design prototypes for large-scale part production. Both techniques are widely used across various industries due to their incredible efficiency and versatility.

Industry	Sinker EDM – Typical Applications	Wire EDM – Typical Applications
Mold & Die Manufacturing	Injection mold core and cavity inserts, die-casting molds, compression and blow molds, deep cavities, sharp internal corners, surface texturing	Punches and dies, die plates, mold inserts, ejector and stripper plates, precision profiles
Automotive	Plastic injection mold tooling, transmission and engine die tooling, connector and housing molds	Stamping dies, gear profiles, splines, keyways, precision sensor and connector components
Aerospace	Turbine blade mold tooling, precision fixtures, form tools, complex cavities in heat-resistant alloys	Turbine disk profiles, precision brackets, thin-wall structural components in superalloys
Medical Devices	Disposable medical part molds, implant tooling with complex internal geometries, micro-cavity molds	Surgical instruments, orthopedic implant components, precision titanium and stainless steel parts
Electronics & Semiconductors	Connector molds, lead-frame molds, micro-feature tooling for electronic housings	Motor and transformer lamination stacks, fine-feature conductive parts, EMI shielding components
Energy & Power Generation	Forging dies, extrusion dies, wear-resistant tooling components	Precision turbine and generator components, nuclear-grade hard material parts
Tooling & Precision Engineering	Hardened steel tooling with complex 3D features, engraving and texturing	Jigs, fixtures, gauges, prototypes, high-accuracy low-volume parts

Choosing the right EDM manufacturing technology for your project

The effectiveness of choosing the right EDM service depends on several factors, such as the material being processed, the required geometry, the required precision and accuracy, and the throughput. It all depends on your part requirements.

If you need to machine deep, complex shapes with intricate cavities in hard or thick materials, especially in small-batch production, then wire electrical discharge machining (Sinker EDM) should be chosen. If you require high precision, fine surface finishes, and tight tolerances, especially in high-volume production and with thin materials, then wire EDM should be chosen. Evaluating these factors will help you select the electrical discharge machining (EDM) process that best suits your project’s specific needs.

Get high-precision custom parts manufacturing services from Xtproto

At Xtproto, our facility boasts extensive practical experience to meet even more detailed tolerance requirements of ±0.0002 inches (0.005 mm). Furthermore, our facilities offer a wide selection of materials, including aluminum, polymers, copper, steel, and other hardened metals. From small-batch prototypes to custom mass production of components, we leverage our best in-house facilities to ensure the reliability and excellence of your projects, while completing them in less time. Trust the precision and quality Xtproto provides for your projects and enjoy a superior customer experience. Contact us now for an immediate quote.

in conclusion

Understanding the characteristics, advantages, and limitations of Sinker EDM and Wire EDM is crucial for selecting the most suitable machining method. Each process has its own strengths and is suitable for different machining tasks. Sinker EDM excels at machining complex shapes on any conductive material, while Wire EDM is better suited for machining tasks requiring high precision, high surface finish, and complex cutting geometries.

Each technology excels in different areas. Sedimentation excels in manufacturing complex 3D cavities. Wire EDM, on the other hand, offers good cutting speeds and higher surface quality for 2D contours. The choice between them depends on variables such as part material properties, shape, cost factors, and production volume. Understanding these differences is crucial for achieving desired results and improving manufacturing workflows.

FAQ